First of all, you've got your scenario wrong.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by w-thompson The initial caller goes in the tank but he finally folds, showing A  K  . I triumphantly roll over A  A  and the villain rolls over her A  K  . |
The AcKc pushed, the AKo folded (not that the folded AK had much effect on the %s):
Dead: As Kh
_________equity__win____tie
AdAh: 87.829% 87.17% 00.66%
AcKc: 12.171% 11.51% 00.66%
Second, if you define
bad beat as simply any hand winning that was say a 4-to-1 dog or worse, well then I guess this is a bad beat.
A bad beat to me is when the other player makes a terrible play (read: gets horrible pots odds), but catches some 2-outer or crazy runner-runner to suck out.
What happened here is a cold deck maybe, but you can't fault the player for pushing preflop with AK suited. With the Ac and Kc in your hand, there's only 6 total ways to make AA or KK. So you'd be more apt to put the initial raiser on something like Queens, Jacks or AQ.
Although in re-reading this I noticed WT doesn't say it was a bad beat, only that his Aces got cracked. So I should catalog this under Poker Stories, not Bad Beats
