[imthatguy]

Originally Posted by links_slayer

x2

but at least you guys can see the pics...all i see is the red x of desire.

Can you see me now?

[links_slayer]

Originally Posted by imthatguy

Can you see me now?

*sigh*

unfortunately, yes.

Seriously, those look friggin' h.o.t.

[Garyon]

Originally Posted by imthatguy

You're losing me. What exactly are you trying to argue here? Does it boil down to you being unhappy because these chips contain elements that were contained in previous iterations of his chips that also happened to be elements in a design you created?

LMAO!! I am a long way from unhappy!

I guess most people don't understand the history here so it may be somewhat confusing ... but since it's been brought up ... I will elaborate ...


I don't want to speak for MS Patton here (but, if you've noticed ... he's said nothing)... but here's MY interpretation of what this post is REALLY all about ...

MS Patton has an issue with the design I did for Palm Imports (based on a flame mail he sent some time ago). He is attempting to make his point by posting these knock-offs of my design in an effort to make HIS argument. I am simply pointing out that this "Private Cardroom" design is not a knock-off of his other designs ... and neither is MINE.

This IS, however,a knock-off the "Private Cardroom" design that was done for Palm Imports. Not because it uses the same elements ... but because of the position and scale and similarity of the use of those elements in the overall design nearly duplicates their use in the "PI Private Cardroom" design.

I would certainly welcome the opinion of a patent or copyright attorney if we have one in the forum! My cousin is a patent/copyright attorney but to be honest ...I can't afford him!! LOL

Originally Posted by ontheuptick

I'm confused as well. I have NO IDEA what Garyon is trying to claim. I can't tell if he's claiming that MSPatton's design is fine, or if it is "stolen" design, or what he's saying. What are you really saying Garyon?

The question is ... what is MS Patton really saying? What's with this post? He's knowingly posted a set of obvious knock-off inlays, and added absolutely NO comment to the OP. Just ... "here ya go"... Why ... ?
He's trying to get me on tilt!! LMAO!

I had actually tried to handle this with him privately and thought that we were done with it ... I guess not!

[Garyon]

Originally Posted by imthatguy

Can you see me now?

All the bickering and B.S. aside these are some seriously SWEET looking chips! I love the colors and edgespots, although I would be curious to see how clearly the finer details would print. We had some difficulty getting the perimeter text crisp on the outer rim.

I was never a fan of the Paulson Web Mold, but must admit I like it here. Good choice!

A Very impressive version of the "Private Cardroom"!

[tastic]

I LOVE that 100 white chip...webmolds rock!

[ontheuptick]

All I can say is, if MSPatton SERIOUSLY think that the PI Private Cardrooms are a knockoff of a few of his chips (Samurai, Speakeasy), that's among the most laughable things I've ever heard. They aren't even close, IMO.

Originally Posted by Garyon

LMAO!! I am a long way from unhappy!

I guess most people don't understand the history here so it may be somewhat confusing ... but since it's been brought up ... I will elaborate ...


I don't want to speak for MS Patton here (but, if you've noticed ... he's said nothing)... but here's MY interpretation of what this post is REALLY all about ...

MS Patton has an issue with the design I did for Palm Imports (based on a flame mail he sent some time ago). He is attempting to make his point by posting these knock-offs of my design in an effort to make HIS argument. I am simply pointing out that this "Private Cardroom" design is not a knock-off of his other designs ... and neither is MINE.

This IS, however,a knock-off the "Private Cardroom" design that was done for Palm Imports. Not because it uses the same elements ... but because of the position and scale and similarity of the use of those elements in the overall design nearly duplicates their use in the "PI Private Cardroom" design.

I would certainly welcome the opinion of a patent or copyright attorney if we have one in the forum! My cousin is a patent/copyright attorney but to be honest ...I can't afford him!! LOL



The question is ... what is MS Patton really saying? What's with this post? He's knowingly posted a set of obvious knock-off inlays, and added absolutely NO comment to the OP. Just ... "here ya go"... Why ... ?
He's trying to get me on tilt!! LMAO!

I had actually tried to handle this with him privately and thought that we were done with it ... I guess not!

[TheDuke]

Originally Posted by ontheuptick

All I can say is, if MSPatton SERIOUSLY think that the PI Private Cardrooms are a knockoff of a few of his chips (Samurai, Speakeasy), that's among the most laughable things I've ever heard. They aren't even close, IMO.

X2

When I first saw the PI chips I didn't even think of the Speakeasys or Samurais. Upon closer inspection the scroll art is very similar to that of the Speakeasys - I'll give him that. But the overall design of the PI inlay doesn't even look close.

These chips on the other hand are obviously 'inspired' by the PI chips.

In any case, it's win-win for the chip buyer as both chips are very nice.

[links_slayer]

Originally Posted by tastic

I LOVE that 100 white chip...webmolds rock!

no joke. i wanna roll around in a bathtub full of those.

[Sneds]

I was wondering if we could have one of those pictures of a ship sailing into a huge storm with 'I like where this thread is going'

[Garyon]

Originally Posted by links_slayer

no joke. i wanna roll around in a bathtub full of those.

You're analogy is a riot ... I had to buy a bed mattress instead of my BCC "Dragon's Lair" chips last year ... my girlfriend kept giving me a hard time by saying "I can't wait to sleep on those chips" ... I was saying the same thing ... difference was ... I WAS SERIOUS!!

LMAO!!