[jdunford]

So, which is it?

1. Orange 1/4, Pink 1/6 (358)
   
2. Pink 1/4, Orange 1/6 (358)
   
3. Something else
   (please post suggestions)

[jdunford]

Do keep in mind what other chips have been decided upon. They might undergo minor tweaks, but more-or-less looks like:



Please ignore the 4d14 orange option (it lost its poll; I just haven't updated that mock-up yet). And the poll for the red, (dark) green, and black chips... ends tomorrow evening!! Go vote if you haven't already, and I'll be updating those options soon, too.

[jdunford]

How about this as a possible "Something Else"?

Keep the Pink quarter-pie, make the Blue a 358 (maybe one of those pictured below), and have the Orange be a 4a12:

[MeridianFC]

Since the Orange 4D14 didn't seem to pass muster, does anyone care for a Pink 4D14?


By meridianfc at 2008-02-23

[jadillon]

Pls. ignore the sarcasm, but how about no! 412 and 4A12 look like *ss IMHO. And they don't go with the rest of the set. Besides, people seem to like the Orange/Arc Yellow combo. All these color choices have been rejected in older polls. BTW why in the name of ChipTalk would you get rid of the only 3U in the set? Makes no sense to me. If you are going to explore options like that, at least please explore orange 3Us that don't look like *ss. For instance,

Originally Posted by jdunford

How about this as a possible "Something Else"?

Keep the Pink quarter-pie, make the Blue a 358 (maybe one of those pictured below), and have the Orange be a 4a12:

[the3rd]

I don't understand. If orange pie won the poll, wouldn't that make the pink 358?

[jdunford]

Originally Posted by the3rd

I don't understand. If orange pie won the poll, wouldn't that make the pink 358?

The orange "pie" poll was between a "pie-type" option (1/4 or 358 ) vs. the 4d14 option that had been proposed. And the pink had already been "penciled in" as a 1/4-pie. But several pro-pie people had said they'd prefer the orange be the 1/4-pie and the pink be the 358. This poll is to decide between those two options.

As for why mess with it at all... I would definitely like to see the 3U stay in the set, but had thought that a 4d14 would be cool on the orange chip, freeing up the 358 for the blue, l
like this:



I think this is my favourite mock-up yet... but the 4d14 Orange lost in the last poll, and some people have voiced their disliking for "radioactive blue".

[smitty007]

Here are my inputs for the yellow, blue, & arc yellow...the pink I like how it has been for some time in the mock-ups

[Chiproll]

so far i havent liked any pink chip i've seen, no offense to those who submitted them. I voted 2. tho so atleast the orange chip which i do like would get the vote. best i could do in two minutes for the pink chip:

sctm pink.jpg

btw that arc yellow (or is it orange)/white 358 above looks awesome.

[smitty007]

Originally Posted by Chiproll

so far i havent liked any pink chip i've seen, no offense to those who submitted them. I voted 2. tho so atleast the orange chip which i do like would get the vote. best i could do in two minutes for the pink chip:

Attachment 9072

btw that arc yellow (or is it orange)/white 358 above looks awesome.

That's Arc Yellow w/ White 358...I like it too!