Miles,
I like the theme and the "hook"... "you won't get boned"

sorry couldn't resist the obvious and bad pun.
I worked with Brent on my BR Pro's as well. I think symetry works with certain chips, but for this design, I am going to disagree with the previous posts and say that having a jumbled look is perfect..
A splashy look should be played up I think.
Think water, waves, ripples, splashing and the fish bones.
You could also go more beachy with it and change the lettering to a TiKi style font which would look pretty cool too and drop the "fish shape" lettering altogether.
ooohh...here's an idea, have the chip look like you're looking at it partially under water somehow...
Just writing and thinking as I go. so the bones are ON the beach just washed up on shore. I can visualize it, so maybe Brent can work it. assuming it's something that appeals to you.
The BR Pro chips do have a slight "sandy" feel to them ...
Anyways...just throwing some stuff at ya. It's times like this when I want to run out and buy Illustrator just to whip up my ChipDesigns...
Capstone
PS...just one more thing...you might consider dropping the .50 cent Denom off the pink chip and leave it blank (and dare I suggest... possibly consider Yellow?) ...that way the chip can serve both ends of the Number sequence for use in both Cash and Tourneys alike