(Decided) Protege Inlay Design Face-Offs (Poboy -vs- X-Files)

[Sidepot]

One vote per elibigle CT member. 48 hour voting period.

[Wedge Rock]

Wow - tough matchup early...

I have to go with X-files... Poboys is simple and elegant, the denom font is excellent... but it may be *too* plain...

[Magus 23]

Yeah, this one's really tough for me, too. Part of me really likes the simple elegance of Poboy's design -- reminiscent of old-style ivory chips -- but another part thinks it may be too simple for this type of chip.

(Just one opinion, of course -- and not a very firm one at that.)

[on tilt]

I've been looking at these for 5 minutes and I still can't decide. A very tough matchup. Both great designs.

[Anborn]

poboy's simplicity wins for me. some of the design elements on the xfiles inlay somehow get lost for me.

[ahopen78]

fyi, there are a few inelligble voters voting...

Anborn, you are one of them...

[Poboy]

You may have fooled everyone else X-Files, but I know you've got 74 other accounts. The Truth is Out There.

[jello-broom]

Apparently I'm in the minority, but I think between this face-off, less is more, so I had to go with Poboy's inlay.