[skull_leader]

saw this on ebay...

http://cgi.ebay.com/Pres-New-Yorker-...QQcmdZViewItem

listing says "These are finest quality chips, better than Vineyard, guaranteed."

as an owner of a set of vineyards, i say prove it.

[noelsarchs]

Originally Posted by skull_leader

saw this on ebay...

http://cgi.ebay.com/Pres-New-Yorker-...QQcmdZViewItem

listing says "These are finest quality chips, better than Vineyard, guaranteed."

as an owner of a set of vineyards, i say prove it.

Yes, I also wrote to this person asking the same question and where she gets her proof of this claim seeing as I own both types....of course I bid on the set anyway when I saw it...That said, it is a difficult comparison because one could argue that the Vineyards, Olivia's and New Yorkers could be the best looking when comparing these three full or giant overlay chips. A subjective design issue but I love all 3 chips myself and would be hard pressed to choose between the three.

[Kinjora]

I peronally like the Vineyards only because I live 50 miles away from where the Casino (Now Vineyards Church) used to be.
&)

[Harlequin011]

Originally Posted by skull_leader

saw this on ebay...

http://cgi.ebay.com/Pres-New-Yorker-...QQcmdZViewItem

listing says "These are finest quality chips, better than Vineyard, guaranteed."

as an owner of a set of vineyards, i say prove it.

Are you saying that someone on ebay has put another useless guarantee on their opinion? Who ever heard of such a thing!?

c'mon guys its ebay. Its certainly not the pinacle of truth and honest representation.


That being said. My New Yorkers are much better than the Vineyards I don't own or have ever handled.

[skull_leader]

Originally Posted by Harlequin011

My New Yorkers are much better than the Vineyards I don't own or have ever handled.

be careful... those are fighting words...

this rivalry could be up there with duke vs. north carolina...

ohio state vs. michigan...

or the biggest one of all... britney vs. christina...

[poislb]

I love the 7 dollar shipping charge this person is asking.....mmmmmmmmm, 7 bucks for 7 chips, yeah that adds up....Gotta love ebay.

[mr.aol]

I think Vineyard is much better. Look at Vineyard colors; especially $2, $3, and $5.

[Vitesse304]

I also prefer the colors and design of the vineyards...I'm not much into the presidents!

[jldecarlo]

Originally Posted by Kinjora

I peronally like the Vineyards only because I live 50 miles away from where the Casino (Now Vineyards Church) used to be.
&)

When this is the reason you prefer one line of chips over another, the chips must be pretty similar in quality.

Nothing wrong with this reason, or "I like the colors better" or "I like the twin towers" or whatever.

PNYs, Olivias, Vineyards, Crystal Parks are all beautiful B&M Casino Paulson's. There isn't an objective reason to choose one over another. I would love to have a set of each.

L