A Whole Mess of Pharaoh's cheap. Discuss A Whole Mess of Pharaoh's cheap, on ChipTalk.net the place to go for your Poker chips and gambling tips. Read it in Auction Links.
The shipping label on my first 650 JBs said $35 for parcel post, so I would imagine that $85 is pretty fair for 1837 chips.
You can ship 1,000 chips in a flat rate priority box for $8.50. It's twice as fast as parcel post too. Make sure you tape up the box well. I learned this the hard way.