[MeridianFC]

Obviously you were unclear of the rule at the time, but in future you should separate all side pots as soon as they are formed. So in the first round of betting you'd make a pot that contained what the all in player could win, and place it more towards that player, and then a second pot with all subsequent action. I find it helpful to remind the players to keep their cards down as there is still live action, many players are tempted to toss their cards up as soon as they're all in.