[OnTheButton]

How could anyone have known her hand (to tell the story) if she mucked it?

You either flip, or you muck, you don't typically get to do both. Aren't there cameras for this?

Unless the story is trying to say that he went all in, and she showed and mucked, (not called) and gave him the $500 pot.... Which would defeat the purpose of the "tension" between them and their competetive natures, jackpot or not.

I smell it on that story from here...